Skip to content
Evidence

Does it get the numbers right?

We converted real workbooks, opened them in the real products, and compared every formula's result with the value the original calculated. Here's what came out.

Almost every cell, every time

With SheetSure99.99%of formula cells give the same result in Google Sheets as in Excel.
Google's own import, same files70.0%of the same cells come out right when the files are imported untouched.

126,268 formula cells in 27 real workbooks, each converted file opened by Google Sheets' own import, the way you'll open yours. What's left over, the 0.01%, is explained on the page about how we test.

Real workbooks, start to finish

  • A Spanish payroll196 / 196formulas matchIts locale, Spanish (Spain), was detected from the file. Opened with US settings instead, 46 of these cells would have come out different.
  • A large model1,916 / 1,916formulas matchEvery formula matches. Two conditional-formatting rules couldn't be carried over, and the report lists them.
  • A workbook built on Excel tables280 / 280formulas matchFormulas like =SUM(Sales[Amount]) are rewritten as ordinary ranges Google Sheets understands.
  • A workbook linked to other files73 / 73formulas matchIts 270 links to another workbook can't work in Google Sheets: they keep Excel's values, so everything that reads them still adds up, and they're listed.

What still needs you

Two settings Google Sheets doesn't take from the file, and the few things that don't convert. The site tells you about each one for your workbook.

The locale

Google's import gives the new Sheet your own settings, not the author's. We detect the right one from the file and show you where to set it.

Circular references

Models that calculate in circles show #REF! in Google Sheets until iterative calculation is on. We give you the exact setting, only when your workbook needs it.

No equivalent

Links to other workbooks, web lookups, data cubes, What-If tables. They keep their value, so the formulas that read them still work.

Not migrated

Pivot tables, images, macros, data bars, icon sets, dropdowns that grow with a list, chart trendlines. The Report tab lists any your workbook has.

Don't take our word for it

The file you get back checks itself. Open it in Google Sheets, and its Report tab compares every converted cell with Excel's value, calculated by Google Sheets in your own file. Try it on a workbook you know well.

How we test, and every result →For anyone signing off on a migration: six collections of real workbooks, whether the Report tab can be trusted, and what still differs.